A few weeks ago, on Friday, August 29, 2008, we went through can after can of Goya Black Beans (Frijoles Negros) looking for one that wasn’t spoiled-looking. We couldn’t believe that so many in a row were ruined. They had a nasty grayish-white sludge on top, some worse than others.
I jumped on Google and found one blog post about the same issue, on Erin Cooks. She just kept buying more cans, but we don’t roll that way. We sent the following note to Goya:
Goya,We just threw out six cans of “Goya Black Beans (Negro Frijoles)” because they were all spoiled. Each can had greyish-white foam and chunks on top and had a bizarre odor. We regularly buy Goya black beans and kidney beans and have never seen this before.
In addition to ruining the dinner we were going to make tonight — we were shocked to see this many cans that were bad. We checked the expiration date on the bottom of each can before throwing them out and each had the same expiration date in 2011; they were in a package of six purchased from a BJs in Queens.
We would, at the minimum, like a refund for these!
Exactly two weeks later (this past Friday), we received a response from Goya:
Hello and thank you for contacting GOYA Foods.This is in response to your email, concerning the above-mentioned product. We always appreciate when consumers such as you take the time to bring concerns to our attention.
We certainly regret that you felt dissatisfied with our product. Goya values all our consumers by providing the best quality products available.
We appreciate the concerns that you have raised and have carefully reviewed them.
In response to the complaint, we advise you that due to the warmer weather coming in sooner then expected, the black beans were growing in very dry causing the liquid to solidify and a higher amount of starch, (white/grayish substance) to accumulate leaving the beans in a mashed state.
A test has been conducted to make sure there is nothing wrong with the beans and it turns out that this poses no health hazard and nutrient value is the same
As a token of our appreciation for contacting us, we are sending you a reimbursement for this product.
Kindest Regards,
GOYA Foods, Inc.
The most important outcome is for anyone else who finds this blog post, don’t throw away the beans! They’re safe to eat, although disgusting looking (we’re still not sure we would eat it).
This seems like the kind of news that would’ve had a press release, or at least there would be a note on their web site (perhaps next to the product?). Alas, there was none. And interestingly, as you can probably tell from the various typos in the e-mail they sent, it doesn’t seem like they’ve got a form response put together.
We’re satisfied with Goya’s response, because we’ll be refunded for the product, and because they’re aware of the issue, have tested, and feel it’s safe to eat. That is corporate responsibility in action, and it’s what’s expected.
We like Goya alot, so we had higher hopes. They need to be a bit more proactive, either putting a note on suspect cans or on their website or something. Their response shouldn’t have taken two weeks, they should’ve had a customer service response ready for this issue and just sent it out. But we set the bar high.
Filed under News, Products. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
Thanks for letting me know that I wasn’t alone in the bad bean fiasco. I truly couldn’t believe how many cans we opened/bought. It was like an episode of The Twilight Zone. I honestly haven’t purchased any Goya products since this incident. I’ve been using beans from Whole Foods exclusively. I never wrote to Goya myself as I hadn’t taken any photos of the beans and assumed they’d want some sort of proof, but my cans looked exactly like the ones you’ve posted here. While customer service appears to claim that the beans are OK to eat, I doubt I would ever serve anything that looks so gnarly straight from a can – testing or no testing. I also agree with you that it is very irresponsible of them not to have addressed this issue in a mass press release.
Yuck! Glad they reimbursed you.
Ever since going to cooking school I have learned all about botulism, which you mostly acquire from anything canned. So if there is any bulge in the can, throw it away. Yeah, those beans look nasty, but they are probably fine.
We are always amazed how most big companies miss the mark in customer service – go Goya (almost makes me want to eat beans).
By the way, the timing does make a little sense in that they did testing, but ideally they would have sent a quick note immediately to let you know they will be doing testing.
Also, for you parents out there, we had a great customer service response after purchasing a defective sippy cup from NUBY. They sent a new cup and reimbursed us for shipping the old one to them so their engineers could look into it.
Erin, I agree, I wouldn't eat something that looks like that even if they say it's safe to eat.
Asianmommy, yes, that's the very least I would accept.
Manger La Ville, glad you're enjoying your ServSafe classes.
K&S;, customer service leaves a big impression!
i get goya products all the time but i’ve never had this particular misfortune. i think you handled it very well.
thanks Grace!
They just look like mashed beans.
I usually rinse my canned beans but I am sure this would’ve caused me pause as well!Glad that they reimbursed you for the ones you threw away!
Jacqueline, I don’t know if the pic is clear enough but they looked like mashed beans that were GRAY.
Deborah, I tried rinsing it but they were all caked together.
Thanks for this — we almost just threw ours out.
Oh gosh, I’m so hungry! All 4 cans are like that. I opened and took pics, also called customer service but no one answered. Awww, I’m sure I’ll get sick if I eat this. It looks waxy and bad. I cant afford to take the risk since im pregnant. I can’t tell if they are good just by smell.
throwing them out wether they are actually good or not.
Laura, Goya says there is no problem with them but better safe than sorry, especially when pregnant!!
08/18/11… i had 3 cans 1 was monday and then i opened one can i saw the samec as in the pic.. then i opened anouther can.. same. now i then opened a can of goya red small beans,was good. iwill know longer buy goya.. $ 3 is not worh it !
I threw out two cans last night. There was white/gray liquid and foam on top and the beans were complete mush- like bean paste.
I’m throwing them away…. Just opened 3 cans from BJ’s too. Makes me wonder if all the bad batches went to BJs. Just doesn’t look appetizing. And don’t know what to eat now tonight!
i had some grayish gooey stuff at the top of my can of goya black beans today. i rinsed the beans off, and made a cold quinoa salad with them. i hope someone lets ya’ll know if i die from this. delicious.
I just had the same thing happen. My beans look just like the ones in the picture. Good to know they are safe to eat, but I don’t think I’ll be buying Goya anymore
I buy Goya black beans from BJ’s. All of the cans I opened had that white goopy stuff. The first can I rinsed but I was not taking any chances with the other cans. I don’t care what they say I never saw this before no matter what the weather. I have been eating Goya beans for years. I think they have changed something in the processing and don’t want to say. I am using the dried beans now. It is more work but I feel safer.