As some of you may have noticed by now, I’ve been spending a lot of time in Murray Hill, at a client lately. The largest deli in the area is Susie’s Kitchen Susie’s Kitchen. It’s the same as many other delis in the city, just larger. They have a salad station, burrito station, sandwich/deli counter, hot/cold buffet, wide drink selection, pre-made sushi, and various soups and miscellaneous other standard fare. If they’re so typical, why am I calling them out?
Susie’s Kitchen is the worst deli in Manhattan! The clerks who work there are nice, so that’s not an issue; although the sandwich clerks have never assembled a sandwich correctly (for me or others I witness). But the main problem is their food — it’s consistently horrible. Figuring out how they manage to produce such horrible tasting items is beyond me. It might be the ingredients?
For example, their roast beef, is served semi-frozen, along with the thickly-sliced tomato they put on it. Their chicken has zero flavor. I tried a burrito and it tasted like a bag of over cooked rice. On the buffet last week they had a huge pile of fried whole fish (they looked like sardines). What deli puts that out? I was not surprised that at 2:30pm the entire pile was still there.
And, finally, the oddest part. A few times I’ve eaten various egg-based breakfasts (sandwiches, burrito, platters) from Susie’s. They are all horrible. I recommend an experiment. If you have $7 dollars and time to spare: order a sausage, egg, and cheese on a toasted English muffin from Susie’s. Then walk down the block to the Cafe & Deli, with a brown awning. I believe it’s called AristotleTaza Cafe & Deli Taza. Compare the two. See what a fantastic breakfast and a horrible breakfast are like side-by-side.
Filed under Avoid Like the Plague, Restaurants. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.







Um, why have you gon to Susie’s more than twice?
I’m not as smart as I smell? Honestly, I’ve been there so many times because it is close to my client. However, I won’t be going back any more.
I had been there before when it was Susie’s kitchen and not that it has been changed to ENZO. It is still bad. I will not go back again. Ordered Panini that was ice cold even though it sat on grill for almost 10 minutes. Went by for breakfast and was given wrong muffin twice. I’ve given up on this place and don’t understand why its still open. Happy to have found another place for breakfast and lunch.